Web Analytics RiceHigh's Pentax Blog: Full Review: K-5 Wi-Fi, Q Wi-Fi and EOS 5D6! ;-)

Wednesday, February 06, 2013

Full Review: K-5 Wi-Fi, Q Wi-Fi and EOS 5D6! ;-)


(Above: My New 5D6!~)

Background

I bought this and all my current cameras have now suddenly become Wi-Fi capable! :-D



So, my Pentax Q is now the Pentax Q Wi-Fi, my K-5 is now the K-5 Wi-Fi and my 5D3 is the 5D6 now, which is actually a 5D3 with some of the Wi-Fi features of the 6D two in one!~

Basic Operation

This card has two transfer/connection modes, the first is that the card acts as a Wi-Fi Access Point itself, which is called the "Direct Mode" by the maker and the second is that the card logs in a common Access point so that it can communicate with all other mobile devices that are connected to the same LAN under that AP, which is named as the "Internet Mode".

Software

Install the App for the OS of your device, then photos/videos in the card can be browsed, selected and downloaded. Actually there is nothing to set up for the card and device, what you need to set is only the login username and password when the card acts as an AP (for your mobile devices to log in) and also the AP(s) that the card is to be connected, which a maximum of three AP logins can be remembered. For better security, the user may also wish to change the default admin login and password. That's all of it!

For other devices with other OSes other than the above, e.g., a laptop runs on Windows, the SD card still provides a webpage interface to do the jobs for the same function set. The internal IP address for that webpage is http://192.168.11.254/.

Btw, the full user manual and working instructions of the cards (in 16 and 32GB) can be downloaded from the official Transcend website here.

Compatibility

It should be noted that Transcend has maintained an official list of compatible and incompatible cameras with their this model of the Wi-Fi cards, which they have fully tested, I believe. In fact, my card was programmed with the Firmware version 1.4 which I found was really not compatible with my K-5 (even with the latest Pentax firmware 1.14), but it did work well with both my Q and 5D3 instead. So, their compatible and incompatible lists are 100% correct for what I tested!

So, what I did was to update the firmware to 1.5 (which can be found here, together with full update instructions) and after that I was happy to find that it also works in my K-5 now! :-D Btw, I have not tested it with my other cameras (many) but I hoped that it will work eventually!

Connection Speed and Stability

Overall speaking, I found that the connection is stable and transfer is fast for the "Direct Mode", while in the "Internet Mode" the performance is not that good and it is rather slow, although the connection did not break anyway, last time I tried. I have tested it with my above three cameras and no problem of any was found. One important tip to keep the Wi-Fi connection alive is by always keeping the camera awake when Wi-Fi is needed. This can be easily achieved by either seting a longer power save activation time or to half-press the camera more frequently from time to time when needed.

Power Consumption

As for the power consumption, as any other WiFi cards and devices, it uses up the battery juice quite a bit and the card will become warm after a certain period of use. I found that for device that has a small capacity battery like the Q should be used more cautiously whilst for devices that have a larger battery like my 5D3 and K-5, it is much a lesser problem.

There is one tip of mine to save power yet, that is, to set the auto power off to one (1) minute for the time-out period after the card is powered on but not connected. And at the same time, the camera's auto power off time limit could be set to longer, e.g., 4 minutes for my 5D3 after idling. So, the WiFi SD card will become a normal SD card without wasting power to transmit RF when it is actually not connected - best of both worlds. :-D

Supported File Types

The card and software should support all common photo and video file types. It fully supports JPEG directly without the need of installing any external App. As for other more special file types like the PEF and DNG etc., I have tested it with my Pentax Q in RAW(DNG) mode and it does fully work also! Just press hold (instead of just click directly the file, which will launch the associated App) or use the selection function (if there are more than one files in folder) and download the selected DNG files under the Transcend App's Browser (under the "Others" File Type Tab) and then you can start working with any installed App that can handle the DNG files after they are downloaded. Ditto for the MOV/AVI video files, which can be downloaded under the "Video" File Type Tab instead.

Trick for Using with the 5D3

Btw, there is a special using tip of mine with the 5D3, I think, i.e., with its dual card slots and flexible saving configuration options, I set to record separately with the CF and SD cards. Whilst for the CF card I set to the best quality JPEG or RAW as needed, I set for the SD card to record a small 2.5MP "S2" JPEG which is far smaller and thus much faster to transfer to my mobile devices. Just see the illustration below:-



Conclusion

All in all, this Transcend card is the best buy I can find now and I am impressed with the support, stable software and continuous improvement of its software (including firmware) as a whole package. It is a Class 10 card in 16GB for mine, and it is much cheaper when compared with other (older) alternatives such as the Eye-fi and the Toshiba FlashAir for the same storage size and speed. Do note that both the Eye-fi or FlashAir does require a first-time setup at the computer instead of capable to do the transfer On The Go with *any* Wi-Fi device like that the Transcend can do, without the need of a setup computer. Nonetheless, there are other options of Wi-Fi SD cards like those made by the Chinese brands of PQI and EZ-Share etc., but I do trust Transcend more for the SD card itself as a storage mean as the brand is more famous and well known.

Comments (21)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Hi,
does it work fine with K5-s DNG format ? The android app can read it ?
1 reply · active 631 weeks ago
I have just tested it and it works! Just press hold (instead of just click), select and download the DNG files under the App's Browser (under the "Others" File Type Tab) and then you can start working with any App that can handle the DNG file. Ditto for the MOV video files, which can be downloaded under the "Video" File Type Tab instead.
How easy is it to have the files down loaded directly to Adobe Lightroom and such??
1 reply · active 631 weeks ago
Please see my reply to Arn above.
The compatibility list does not mention the K-x. I'd appreciate knowing if anyone has been able to make it work or not with the K-x. Thanks.
5 replies · active 631 weeks ago
anonimity is great's avatar

anonimity is great · 631 weeks ago

+1
I shall try with my K-x and will tell you the result later.
Just inserted the card into my K-x and K-r, both worked okay.
Thanks for the confirmation! I like the possibility of the geocoding w/ the EyeFi Pro cards, but having usable wifi w/ this Transcend card is very appealing.
Just use a geo-tagging app to insert the data after the pic is downloaded to the mobile device then.
ray weeler's avatar

ray weeler · 631 weeks ago

K-5 is listed as non compatible, how did you manage to use this SD ?
1 reply · active 631 weeks ago
I think I have already mentioned that I upgraded the firmware of the card and it works now.
I´m using a Sandisk Eye-Fi card with my K-5 for over 6 month now to transfer the pics from the camera to a android tablet via the direct mode.
Using the same card in my K-30 works also, but the range of wifi from the eye-fi card is not as wide as in the k-5. I guess that´s coming from the metal chasis of the K-30. Btw. it´s everytime a big fun to show on parties or events the shooten pics immeadiately.
1 reply · active 554 weeks ago
So you are able to make it work pretty easily with your Pentax K30? If so, I think it's worth the purchase for me :)
ray weeler's avatar

ray weeler · 630 weeks ago

It's still not polished product see what they say @ Amazon:

Dear User

Please accept our sincere apologies for the inconvenience you may have experienced in respect to the problem with the Transcend WiFi Card.

Our app version in this moment doesn't automatically download all the pictures to the mobile device; however, you can select what you like and download the selected pictures into your devices, and we are going to update our app soon to make automatically the download of those pictures to mobile devices. Also, our Wi-Fi SD takes 60 sec to transmit 10 pictures (37.2MB), we know is not the best rate of transfer but we are working to make it faster.

Because of this serious oversight, we take your reviews in consideration for improvement in our product.

We deeply value your relationship with Transcend and we are committed to providing you with the highest level of service simply because our customers deserve the very best. If you have any further questions or comments regarding this matter, please feel free to discuss it with us at 1-800-886-5590 ext 2244 or techsupport-us@transcend-info.com

Best regards

Captain Transcend.
Hi Rice! I´ve been waiting for a review like this on the Trascend Wifi Card!

I've been thinking about buying a wi-fi SD card for my camera for some months but in the end i thought i were not going to use it much. All that changed when I tried the new Canon 6D.

Bare with me a little when i try to compare the function of the Eye-Fi with a new option from a Canon 6D.

My friend bought a Canon 6D and we tested the Wi-Fi option and is a joy to use!The EOS Remote is really easy to setup and use in your android / ios smartphone or tablet and the streaming photo preview is really fast! You get the picture almost instantly after snapping one on the camera, and you can control the camera from the smartphone / tablet a live view where you can focus and shoot. When you want to download a picture you just click the download button (no matter if its jpg or raw) and you have a small 2mb file on your camera (you can download a bigger version if you want.)

So after testing the functionality I was hooked and bought the Eye-Fi Connect X2 (4GB) for my 5D III, but after testing it the whole process is a disgrace, from the set-up of the card (involving a sign in process over the internet for proper setup even if you just want to use direct mode in an offline configuration) to the regular use where you have little control of what happens to the pictures you want to transfer.

You can't control which pictures you want to transfer, sometimes is very difficult to connect to the card, you have to download a configuration file from the Eye-Fi website for your smartphone / tablet in order to connect with the card.

Also, every picture transfer takes at least 8 seconds (using the small jpg file size in the Canon 5D III) instead of the almost instant availability of previews with the EOS solution. This is the fastest way to setup the card if you have a dual slot DSRL, but is even more cumbersome if you have only on memory slot and if you shoot big resolution JPG's or worst RAW!

The Eye-Fi seems to be a insteresting solution on paper but fails on so many levels, from the pain during set-up, to the lame app and the slow process to transfer the photos.

Can you comment on the main differences between the Eye-Fi and the Trascend? Is there any option for gps geotagging?
1 reply · active 630 weeks ago
I have not handled an Eye-Fi card so far, so I can't comment on the real differences from the practical point of view.

As for the Transcend, the download speed in direct mode is fast, whilst in Internet mode is slow. As for geo-tagging, theoretically it can be done by Apps after you have downloaded the photos into your phone. However, I haven't tried it out myself yet.

Btw, the 6D can be remotely controlled via the EOS Remote App installed in the phone and the Live View image is displayed on the phone also, which is impossible with just an Wi-Fi SD card, or yet not possible even with the WFT-E7 add-on Wi-Fi adaptor with the EOS Utility software.
These cards pair very well with ShutterSnitch on iPad. Here's my setup: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGGBOxvhHZg
I have an EyeFi card, and generally it works well, when I get home it dumps all the photos in nice dated directories on my computer.

But what i can't get it to do is maintain that operation, while using the direct mode to selectively pull photos to my phone for sharing while out. With the eyefi direct access it dumps all photos on the phone, which you then have to run the eye fi IOS software when you get home to push all the camera (and the phones) photos to the same computer).

Can the transcend support this backup everything at home, transfer selected to phone model?
1 reply · active 614 weeks ago
>> Can the transcend support this backup everything at home, transfer selected to phone model?

Yes, of course, and why not? :-)
I have an EyeFi card, and generally it works well, when I get home it dumps all the photos in nice dated directories on my computer.

Post a new comment

Comments by