
http://info.xitek.com/pzreview/xitektest/201011/25-54995.html
(in Chinese, English Translation Here (machine-translated))
Lens is tested at different apertures and 100% crops are shown. The lens was tested with a Pentax K-r. Bokeh are checked and wide opened shots are posted. And there are other "normal" sample shots of "real-life" as well.
In particular, look at those wide opened shots at f/2.4, and we would know why a larger aperture / faster lens is always desired if perfect bokeh is wanted:-


Note that the "circles" near the extreme boundaries of the frame (actually closer to the perimeter of the image circle) have become olive shaped owing to the blocking by the lens barrel. So, to get this effect disappeared completely, stopped down is required - typically for one to two stops, depending on the optical design. Hence, assuming that it requires 1.5 stops closed down for the aperture before perfectly round bokeh is obtained, we should not see this effect anymore at f/4, but then the DoF is greatly increased as a result.
In fact, the "blocking" effect for bokeh happens more often for zoom lenses which usually suffer more than primes, owing to a longer lens barrel for zooming which results in even more blocking for such a zooming design. It is therefore prime lenses are still required for more demanding purposes and this included, i.e., for all perfectly round bokeh for background highlights and objects. However, with small fastest apertures of many of those digital Pentax DA primes, this key prime lens advantage has been diminished, frankly speaking.
illdefined · 741 weeks ago
the DA primes are for size and price, the FA primes all have bigger apertures but are bigger and more expensive because of it. Pentax gives us a choice.
RiceHigh 110p · 741 weeks ago
illdefined · 741 weeks ago
RiceHigh 110p · 741 weeks ago
illdefined · 741 weeks ago
btw, sounds like you're already 3/4 of the way to switching already, where is the post on the 7D and the final farewell to Pentax?
RiceHigh 110p · 741 weeks ago
If I had to get the 7D, I would simply get a K-5 instead, or simply a 550D, if it had to be a Canon at least.
Ying · 741 weeks ago
Bokeh is very much a personal taste matter - sure there are general rules of what is considered as nice bokeh and what is ugly, but disregard a lens purely on it's bokeh is like, buying a Lamboghini and complaining about the boot is too small for your shopping.
aka THAT IS NOT THE POINT!!!!
This is a light weight, compact and relatively fast lens with good optical performance and a reasonable price. If those are not good enough for you and you only hang on to you bokeh then you might as well give up photography as a hobby,
Actually I think you are just purely a gadget/gear head, not a photographer.
RiceHigh 110p · 741 weeks ago
J Viviano · 741 weeks ago
I see this on almost any lens that has no aspherical element, which actually tends to do worse things to the bokeh anyways (such as onion rings),
RiceHigh 110p · 741 weeks ago
It's just simple Geometry and Physics after all, nothing more than that.
And of course, for *most* people, we want round bokeh throughout the frame, but not partially.
illdefined · 741 weeks ago